My dogs absolutely love this. I started them out with a bag of the the Dog Joy beef treats, which they practically inhaled. Yesterday bought a 1.5 pound roll each of the Beef and Chicken recipes. We feed them dry dog food (two 3-year-olds, a Sheltie and a JRT) and I used to give them a couple tablespoons of boiled hamburger with their dry food. Now I cut a thick slice of the Freshpet Select and cut into bite-size pieces to add to the dry food. So convenient. I love that the ingredients are healthy, love that it's made in USA and not China, which I absolutely refuse to buy, though having to really read the fine print these days to make sure I'm not. Thank you so much for a healthy product that my dogs love. Sincerely, Jack and Lucy's "mom"