I am so happy to have found this treat that is both healthy for my collie's diet and one that she loves! It is reassuring to know that it is made here in the USA. My extremely intelligent collie shuns most store-bought treats and I really wanted one that was both good for her and I didn't have to prepare. These are pure enough to eat myself and easy to carry in my treat bag, no mess! She never tires of them and always performs eagerly and flawlessly for them.