To set the record straight...I feed my 9# Chihuahua/Terrier mix, Punkin, the Beef and the Chicken Freshpet Select Slice & Serve. I alternate flavors to give her some variety. Before I started feeding Freshpet Select, it was a struggle to get her to eat all of her food and her stools were very loose. She now finishes all of the food in her bowl and her stools are finally normal. I believe that since feeding Freshpet Select to Punkin her skin and hair have improved as well as her energy. She practically acts like a puppy again!