The treats I gave them before that they loved are no longer made so I had to find another one. I seen that Albertson's started stock the Fresh Pet products so I bought the Dog Joy treats. When I got back home I tried the treats on them. They usually question most everything I give them. Not with the Dog Joy, they took them and right away and ran off to eat them. Then the girls came back for more and harassed me for hours to get more. They never did that with their old beef jerky treats.